The Bermuda Government just expressed an undying love for the Royal Gazette.
Tucked into an economic brief meant to build support for a Competition Authority was an unlikely note: heartfelt concern for the daily's survival. The green paper's stated goal was to lower the cost of living by targeting food, healthcare, and utilities. Yet media, not car dealerships eyeing potential mergers or large restaurant chains buying up competitors, got singled out for special attention—just media.
The Ministry of Home Affairs frames this as protecting pluralism—worried that a standard merger review, requiring the opening of books and market-share analysis, could threaten press freedom. But in a market of 64,000 residents where a paper costs $2.50, is media really a cost-of-living driver? Or is Rebecca hearing the many voices in her head classified as pluralism—a pluralism notably, and correctly, diagnosed as civics and education, not economics? The real financial threat to local outlets isn't domestic competition anyway—it's international platforms siphoning ad revenue and now scraping local content with AI, cutting readers off from the original source entirely.
What reads as concern starts to appear as Rebecca peers through the curtain window as the loving family plays, while a soft hand sits gently on the empty cradle and dreams of it being rocked bring a warm joy and radiant smile in the dark.
Normally, customers decide if media stays in the market based on a publisher's commitment to quality journalism. However, the government presenting media in an economic brief under "cost of living"—where a typical household looks at food and utilities that could disrupt a family—makes everyone wonder: what's that sound from behind the curtain?
As a local media buyer, RDIS Bermuda has to evaluate the health of the media ecosystem and its value to the economy. When the government places its media concerns under regulatory legislation and enforcement, that fundamentally changes the market dynamics, since a regulator by its nature monitors and applies force when necessary. So, ultimately, the Bermuda Government is saying it feels it needs to now exert force on local media — regardless of how it is couched, the outcome is the same. Should anyone make a complaint — whether from the government or the public — the RA has to consider it. If it thinks it has merit, the regulator showing up and asking questions triggers a chilling effect.
Additionally, it is problematic to see media placed in the cost-of-living section to argue that media concentration and grocery prices justify the need for a competition authority. The Bermuda media market snapshot shows a diverse landscape: The Royal Gazette (RG) operates a single printing press for 64,000 residents; the Bermuda Broadcasting Company (BBC) operates two TV stations, three radio stations, and a full website offering up-to-the-minute local, international, radio, and TV news; InterIsland operates two radio stations; Harper Digital operates one station; and IRIE FM operates one station (voted best by The Bermudian Magazine).
Furthermore, Bernews and TNN actively compete against the RG, while The Bermudian Magazine, the Yellow Pages, and local movie theaters are all still competing. On top of that, the Bermuda Government operates a national direct-mail service to homes and businesses (at 15–50 cents per home), a back-of-bus billboard service, a cable TV channel, and a streaming channel.
This makes the green paper suspect, as daily news is clearly not concentrated within a single group.
Moreover, the green paper fails to list Bermuda College or the Department of Education for feedback, despite media being a fundamental component of daily life and public discourse